Washington should beware the wrath of China’s consumer — just ask Hyundai and Toyota

Washington should beware the wrath of China’s consumer —  just ask Hyundai and Toyota
That’s somewhat unusual if you consider Beijing’s most recent diplomatic spats with its trading partners.

When relations with South Korea deteriorated last year over Seoul’s decision to deploy a missile shield, Chinese civil society went straight for the jugular.

Yang Bingyang, a former model who’s known online as Ayawawa, encouraged her 2.7 million Weibo followers to boycott Korean products. “Every penny we spend is a vote on our future world!” the state-owned Global Times quoted her as saying. Hyundai Motor Co.’s market share in China was cut almost in half within a month. Lotte Shopping Co.’s local sales tumbled 84 per cent from the March to June quarters of 2017 after local authorities shut stores alleging fire safety violations, and the chain is now pulling out of China altogether.

It was a similar story in 2012, during one of the periodic flare-ups over islands in the East China Sea claimed by both Japan and China. Nationalist crowds ransacked a Toyota Motor Corp. dealership and set a Panasonic Corp. factory ablaze.

To date, there’s been little sign of that sort of thing in this dispute. Despite claims of reduced buying of U.S. soybeans and disruptive import checks on fruit and pork in recent months, the dreaded non-tariff barriers have been confined to regulatory measures, rather than consumer boycotts.

That’s particularly surprising given consumer goods could be Washington’s Achilles’ heel.

China in December overtook the U.S. as the world’s biggest retail market. It’s the largest market by volume for General Motors Co. and the second biggest for Starbucks Corp., which expects sales in the country to overtake those from North America within a decade. Apple Inc. has some $45 billion of revenue there, while Las Vegas Sands Corp. and Wynn Resorts Ltd. would collapse without the dollars flowing from their Macau casinos.

How to account for the relative silence? One explanation is that we’re simply too early in this dispute for the big guns to be brought out.

The expected tit-for-tat response to the US$34 billion of U.S. tariffs Friday is an indication China’s government is still happy with the conventional trade weapons in its armory, and wary of reaching for anything more powerful.

There might be more to it, though. China has been careful to pose as the good guy in this fight. The spectacle of Beijing unleashing nationalist boycotts on Procter & Gamble Co., Coca-Cola Co. and Apple would make that facade harder to maintain, and give ammunition to the U.S. argument that China’s economy is ultimately a tool of the Party.

The lack of consumer boycotts is “a bit unusual, but consistent with the Chinese rhetoric that China would be a defender of the global trading order,” Victor Shih, an associate professor and expert on China at the University of California, San Diego, said. “The reality is that the status quo allows China to protect many of its industries, so China wants to maintain the status quo.”

Don’t count on that forbearance continuing if tensions escalate. In all, Chinese subsidiaries of U.S. companies had about US$223 billion in revenue in 2015, according to Deutsche Bank AG. Reduce those sales by just 20 per cent – a rather modest target, given what consumer boycotts did to Korean firms last year – and you’ve already done US$45 billion in damage, more than equivalent to the 10 per cent tariff the U.S. is threatening to levy on a further US$400 billion of imports if Beijing doesn’t back down.

That’s reason enough for Washington to reduce the temperature of this fight before a chorus of complaints from boycott-battered U.S. companies force it to do so. The Chinese people – reading from a script, to be sure – haven’t spoken yet. Smile at them, pay them, pass them, but do not quite forget.

Syncrude produces 360,000 barrels of oil per day, roughly 10% of all Canadian oil production

Opinion: NAFTA or not, protecting supply management is protecting an ever-dwindling number of ever-wealthier farmers
Read more on National Post
News Topics :
The logo of the Hyundai Motor Co. is displayed at the automaker s showroom in Seoul, South Korea on April 26, 2017. AP / Lee Jin man Published Wednesday, August 30,...
SEOUL, Korea, Republic Of Hyundai Motor said Wednesday its quarterly profit was halved to its lowest level since 2010 as its auto sales in China and the U.S. plunged...
China’s retaliatory tariffs on U.S. goods struck just as one of its biggest meat importers was rushing a shipment from California through Shanghai customs. Now Suzhou Huadong Foods Ltd. is...
BEIJING Apple s US$1, 000 iPhone is a tough sell to Chinese consumers jittery over an economic slump and the trade war with Washington. CEO Tim Cook told shareholders Wednesday...
SEOUL, Korea, Republic Of Hyundai Motor Co. says it has halted production in China as tensions between Seoul and Beijing over an U.S. anti missile system left the company unable...