News

YouTube’s ‘restricted’ setting is blocking some LGBT-themed content, users claim

YouTube’s ‘restricted’ setting is blocking some LGBT-themed content, users claim
Business
Robert Kyncl, YouTube Chief Business Officer, is seen in this file photo from October 2015. YouTube is looking into why some LGBT-themed content was restricted for certain users.  (Danny Moloshok / AP)  

Mon., March 20, 2017

NEW YORK—YouTube says it is looking into why some gay-themed content is being blocked to those browsing YouTube under its “restricted” setting.

Several users complained on Twitter that their videos were categorized as “restricted” for no obvious reasons. This includes coming out stories, a lesbian wedding and a video from YouTube celebrity Tyler Oakley titled “8 Black LGBTQ+ Trailblazers Who Inspire Me.”

The “restricted” designation lets parents, schools and libraries filter out content that isn’t appropriate for users under 18. Turning on the restriction makes videos inaccessible. YouTube calls it “an optional feature used by a very small subset of users.”

It’s unclear whether the types of videos in question are now being categorized as “restricted” for the first time, or whether this is a long-standing policy that is only now getting attention.

The complaints spawned the hashtag #YouTubeIsOverParty over the weekend. One person even made a video to voice her complaints.

YouTube said in a tweet Sunday that LGBTQ videos aren’t automatically filtered out, though some discussing “more sensitive issues” might be restricted. But the company, which is owned by Google, did not specify what it counts as “more sensitive issues.”

In an emailed statement on Monday, YouTube said “some videos that cover subjects like health, politics and sexuality may not appear for users and institutions that choose to use this feature.” In the case of LGBT topics, which are by definition intertwined with health, politics and sexuality, filtering out what is and isn’t appropriate can be difficult.

YouTube content creators can decide to age-restrict their videos themselves. But that’s just one of the ways sensitive content is filtered out. YouTube says it also uses “community flagging,” which means users who have a problem with content in a video can flag it to YouTube for possible restrictions or removal.

But just because something is flagged, it is not automatically removed. Once a video is flagged, YouTube says it reviews it.

“If no violations are found by our review team, no amount of flagging will change that and the video will remain on our site,” YouTube says in its online support page.

What sorts of content gets filtered out in restricted mode can vary by region, based on countries’ varying community standards. In general, though, it includes “sexually explicit language or excessive profanity,” or violence or disturbing content, according to YouTube’s policies.

YouTube’s rules also state that videos “containing nudity or dramatized sexual conduct may be age-restricted when the context is appropriately educational, documentary, scientific or artistic. Videos featuring individuals in minimal or revealing clothing may also be age-restricted if they’re intended to be sexually provocative, but don’t show explicit content.”

Videos that show adults engaging in “activities that have a high risk of injury or death” may also be age-restricted.
Read more on Toronto Star
News Topics :
Similar Articles :
Technology
Stage crew workers prepare the set for a keynote speech by YouTube at the 2012 International Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas, Thursday, Jan. 12, 2012. AP / Julie Jacobson...
Top Stories
“If you put YouTube on restricted mode a bunch of our music videos disappear ... SAD ” tweeted Calgary raised sisters Tegan and Sara.   Arthur Mola / Invision    Mon., March 20, 2017 A...
Top Stories
A chorus of Canadian LGBTQ YouTubers, including pop duo Tegan and Sara, is calling for the video service to stop filtering out gay and trans themed videos for some users. The...
Technology
YouTube personality Tyler Oakley speaks on a panel with first lady Michelle Obama to college bound students participating in the Reach Higher initiative s third annual Beating the Odds event in...
Top Stories
YouTube is apologizing to its LGBTQ users for an ongoing technical issue that filters out some gay and trans themed videos for some users. At issue is YouTube’s “restricted” designation, which...