News

Judge determines ripping up negotiated plea deal could compromise trial

Judge determines ripping up negotiated plea deal could compromise trial
Canada
TORONTO—A prosecution decision to renege on a plea bargain after prospective witnesses were told the accused would admit his guilt would deprive the man of a fair trial, an Ontario court has ruled.

As a result, Superior Court Justice Renee Pomerance ordered enforcement of the deal Jon-Paul Fuller had agreed to rather than make him stand trial.

“The question is ... whether the state conduct meets the threshold of an abuse of process,” Pomerance said in her decision released Friday. “The cumulative effect of the state conduct in this case — the disclosure to Crown witnesses and the subsequent repudiation — has deprived the accused of the right to a fair trial.”

Police had charged Fuller over a large marijuana grow operation. As is routine, Fuller and the prosecutor — a senior and highly experienced Crown lawyer — negotiated a pretrial deal in which he would change his plea to guilty in exchange for a 90-day intermittent sentence and $25,000 fine.

A senior regional justice in Windsor, Ont., approved the proposed agreement in October last year, with the deal expected to be confirmed in open court days later.
Read more on Toronto Star
News Topics :
RELATED STORIES :
Canada
Canada’s top military officer is expected to take the stand later this month in a pre trial hearing for Vice Admiral Mark Norman. Norman’s lawyer, Marie Henein, said Gen. Jonathan Vance was...
Top Stories
Its been hell, the 50 year old former Chrysler worker said shortly before his two adult children joined him outside the courthouse for a prolonged, emotional embrace. Im looking forward to resuming...
Top Stories
Defence lawyer, Daniel Topp, said his client launched his bizarre robbery attempt because he was unhappy with the housing available in Ontario and preferred to live in a federal penitentiary....
Top Stories
CRANBROOK, B.C. The leader of a fundamentalist sect that condones plural marriage remained silent as a long awaited trial of two men on polygamy charges began Tuesday in British Columbia....
Top Stories
The leader of a fundamentalist sect that condones plural marriage remained silent as a long awaited trial of two men on polygamy charges began Tuesday in British Columbia. Winston Blackmore had...