Meatless burgers can cost twice as much as the real thing ‚ÄĒ but that might not last for long
|Toronto Star 18 Aug 2019 at 04:26|
A battle of the burger has flared up on the menus of fast-food giants and in the aisles of grocery stores across the country since Beyond Meat, Lightlife, Meatless Farm Co. and others popularized patties made from pea proteins, mung beans or soy in the last year.
Meatless burgers have been around for years, but recent improvements in the manufacturing technology has produced a product that tastes so much like its beefy counterpart, it‚Äôs attracting a mainstream consumer who still eats meat, but is curious about plant-based burgers because they‚Äôre healthier and easier on the environment.
The problem is, meatless burgers can cost more than twice as much as traditional beef burgers, leading many to wonder if the recent influx of new competition ‚ÄĒ including new products from supermarket house brands ‚ÄĒ will put pressure on companies like Beyond Meat to drop their prices.
A 2019 Nielsen study revealed that 43 per cent of Canadian consumers intend to increase plant-based food consumption, and in the last two years they have purchased 4 per cent less meat. But ‚Äúprice is still a problem‚ÄĚ for some plant-based protein brands, said Beena Goldenberg, a spokesperson for the Plant-Based Foods of Canada advocacy group and the chief executive officer at Hain Celestial Canada, which makes Yves veggie burgers.
‚ÄúIt‚Äôs almost elitist food right now,‚ÄĚ she said. ‚ÄúIt is very expensive.‚ÄĚ
A recent peek at grocery stores revealed a pack of two Beyond Meat burgers and a package two patties from Lightlife, a Maple Leaf Foods subsidiary, each sell for about $8, or $4 per patty. The Undeniable Burgers from Loblaw‚Äôs President‚Äôs Choice costs about $10 for a pack of four ($2.50/patty), while the Meatless Farm Co. has priced two patties at $7 ($3.50/patty), Morning Star Farms are selling four for $6.49 ($1.62/patty) and Yves sells its Good Veggie Burger for four for $6.99 ($1.75/patty)
Meanwhile, a President‚Äôs Choice‚Äôs package of eight thick and juicy beef burgers cost $14.99, or $1.87 per patty, less than half the price of the high-end plant-based burgers.
‚ÄúPricing on the Beyond Meat burger is I don‚Äôt think sustainable,‚ÄĚ said Goldenberg. ‚ÄúAt that price you are going to get a certain amount of curiosity, but repeat (buys) when you‚Äôre compared to a meat burger is going to be difficult.‚ÄĚ
Though El Segundo, Calif.-based Beyond Meat has managed to attract financial backing from Leonardo DiCaprio, Jessica Chastain, Snoop Dogg and Bill Gates, the company has yet to turn a profit.
And while it has become the plant-based protein of choice for Tim Hortons sausage breakfast sandwiches, Subway meatballs, Quesada burritos and tacos and Aroma Espresso and A&W burgers, its competitors have been figuring out how to undercut it.
President‚Äôs Choice, for example, has shaved a few dollars off its competitors‚Äô prices with its Undeniable burgers and German supermarket chain Lidl, which has stocked the Beyond Meat brand, started selling in packages of two costing 2.99 euros or about $4.40 ($2.20/patty).
‚ÄúThey are charging a bit less because they are not putting the kind of research in that we are and ‚Ä¶ some are reverse engineering our product line, but they are chasing a ghost because we have already moved on,‚ÄĚ Chuck Muth, Beyond Meat‚Äôs chief growth officer, told the Star.
‚ÄúWe think competition is ultimately going to be good for the category. It is going to be good for consumers, so we understand this and we expect it, but we feel really confident in our product.‚ÄĚ
Beyond Meat recently committed to pricing at least one of its products ‚ÄĒ most likely a plant-based beef item ‚ÄĒ below the cost of meat within the next five years.
Muth knows it‚Äôs no simple task.
Most companies producing plant-based burgers spent years and millions on finding a way to make them taste, feel and bleed like a beef burger.
They work with proprietary technology that costs serious dollars to alter, but is crucial for the product‚Äôs taste. Beyond Meat, for example, has a secretive process that ‚Äúapplies heating, cooling and pressure to align plant-based proteins in the same fibrous structures that you‚Äôd find in animal protein,‚ÄĚ according to its website.
California-based Impossible Foods Inc., which scored a deal with to provide products to Burger King, has a method that is just as intensive because it involves fermenting DNA from soy plants and inserting it into a genetically engineered yeast to create heme, a molecule it says ‚Äúmakes meat taste like meat.‚ÄĚ
‚ÄúIt‚Äôs not something where you can throw five people in a room in a lab and say ‚ÄėFigure this thing out,‚Äô‚ÄĚ said Muth, who added that Beyond Meat employs a team of 70 culinary and science experts.
Then there are the challenges associated with ingredients ‚ÄĒ pea proteins, soy, beans, beets, apples, potato starch and brown rice ‚ÄĒ that sometimes must be sourced from several farms because of seasonality or availability.
Get more business in your inbox
Sign Up Now
Soy isolates are easier to source and cheaper, but Beyond Meat prefers yellow pea proteins grown in Canada, which come with challenges of their own.
‚ÄúThere is a limited amount of pea protein that is grown and sourced in North America,‚ÄĚ said Goldenberg. ‚ÄúThere isn‚Äôt a good supply and it‚Äôs expensive and as a result, it drives the pricing up.‚ÄĚ
Troubles also abound when plant-based burger makers constantly change recipes to simulate meat even more closely.
Beyond Meat recently updated its burger, adding mung bean, rice protein and pockets of fat to increase juiciness and flavour, and ensure that they darken from a red colour when raw to a brown when cooked.
Each alteration introduces the cost of new research and development, ingredients and changes to machinery, packaging and marketing.
Because Beyond Meat and other big brands supply stores and quick-serve restaurants, sometimes they land discounts for bulk buying ingredients.
But supermarkets with product lines have tricks too: long-standing relationships with suppliers, in-house brands with hundreds of items to use similar ingredients for and no need to beg or maintain sales levels to get and keep products in grocer aisles.
Kathlyne Ross, Loblaw‚Äôs vice-president of food product development, said in an email to the Star that the President‚Äôs Choice Undeniable Burger is ‚Äúcompetitively priced‚ÄĚ and the reaction to it has so far been ‚Äúpositive.‚ÄĚ
She would not say whether the grocery goliath had intentionally chosen to sell its plant-based burger for less than its rivals or if it will be looking to reduce the cost.
Robert Carter, a food industry expert at the NPD Group research firm, doesn‚Äôt think a price drop is necessary for now, because people are willing to shell out more for plant-based proteins right now to see what all the hype is about.
‚ÄúThis isn‚Äôt going to be a staple that people eat every day. For some people, this is going to be a couple times a month,‚ÄĚ Carter said. ‚ÄúParticularly in the Canadian market, consumers are not as price sensitive as they are in the U.S.‚ÄĚ
And there‚Äôs a risk to dropping the price.
Businesses reducing the cost of plant-based proteins well beyond competitors are in danger of being seen as an inferior product because they‚Äôre so much cheaper, Carter said.