U.S. Customs and Border Protection head defends agency after deaths of two children
|Toronto Star 30 Dec 2018 at 15:28|
The head of U.S. Customs and Border Protection on Sunday defended his embattled agency after the second death of a migrant child in its custody in less than a month â even as a top Senate Republican promised hearings on the matter.
Appearing on ABC Newsâ âThis Week,â Commissioner Kevin McAleenan said the deaths of the two children, both from Guatemala, wereâjust absolutely devastating for us on every level.â But he also assured that everything was done to care for the childrenâs well-being and prevent the tragedies.
A person holds a picture of seven-year-old Jakelin Caal, who died in a Texas hospital two days after being taken into custody by U.S. border patrol agents in a remote stretch of the New Mexico desert, during her funeral in the village of San Antonio Secortez, 320 km north of Guatemala City, on December 25, 2018. The deaths of Caal, and of 8-year-old Felipe GĂłmez Alonzo, who died last week, have reignited a rancorous debate over the Trump administrationâs now-abandoned policy involving the separation of migrant families at the U.S. border with Mexico.Â Â (JOHAN ORDONEZ / AFP/GETTY IMAGES)
âWhat I can tell you about these two cases â and Iâve looked at our operation reporting, the initial investigative reporting, I looked at the fathersâ statements and interviews â is that our agents did everything they could as soon as these children manifested symptoms of illness to save their lives,â McAleenan said.
McAleenan then detailed what he knew about each case.
Of 8-year-old Felipe GĂłmez Alonzo, who died last week: âIn Felipeâs case, it was actually a Border Patrol agent who noticed his symptoms and made the decision to take him and his father to the emergency room, where he had the treatment of doctors in Alamogordo, New Mexico.â
Of 7-year-old Jakelin Caal, who died early this month: âJakelin was 94 miles away from the nearest Border Patrol station. She started to vomit on a bus ride to that station. Our agents got her there as quickly as they could, where we had a paramedic waiting â an agent whoâs a paramedic, too â to revive her and get her into emergency medical service and life-flight her to a childrenâs hospital in El Paso.â
Jakelinâs father, Nery Caal, has said that neither he nor his daughter were provided water for eight hours while in custody at a remote border facility â a claim that contrasts what CBP has said.
Father of dead Guatemalan boy heard rumours they could cross
The deaths have reignited a rancorous debate over the Trump administrationâs now-abandoned policy involving the separation of migrant families at the U.S. border with Mexico. Even before the deaths, Democrats and many Republicans decried the policy as inhumane and unnecessary. Its adherents have defended it as abiding by the letter of the law and have said it was necessary for border security, because parents canât be held in custody with their children and would otherwise be released.
It is also increasingly colouring the debate over the nine-day-old government shutdown, in which Trump is demanding funding for his border wall and Democrats have declined his request.
Trump weighed in on the childrenâs deaths for the first time Saturday on Twitter, opting to blame Democrats rather than offer condolences.
âBorder Patrol needs the Wall and it will all end,â Trump tweeted.
White House counsellor Kellyanne Conway echoed Trump on Sunday, telling CNNâs âState of the Unionâ that the deaths were tragic but that Democrats were using the children as âpolitical pawns.â
âThe president does not want these children to come on the perilous journey to begin with,â Conway said. âThey are paying now; some of them are paying the ultimate price.â
On the same program, incoming Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Lindsey Graham, R-S. C., said he would hold hearings on the deaths. But he suggested it would focus on the root causes of such familiesâ journeys.
âYes, Iâm going to hold hearings on the deaths of these two children and the policies that entice people to come,â Graham said.
The senator added: âRight now, we have 11,000 unaccompanied minors from Central America; 98 per cent of them never leave. In 2014, (Sen.) Dianne Feinstein (D-Calif.) asked President (Barack) Obama to change our policy. We have an unaccompanied minor from Central America, they should be sent back to their home country, just like if they were from Mexico. Thatâs a legal change we need to make with this (shutdown-border wall) deal.â