News

Researchers examine which approaches are most effective at reducing COVID-19 spread

Researchers examine which approaches are most effective at reducing COVID-19 spread
Science
Simon Fraser University professors Paul Tupper and Caroline Colijn have found that physical distancing is universally effective at reducing the spread of COVID-19, while social bubbles and masks are more situation-dependent.

advertisement

The researchers developed a model to test the effectiveness of measures such as physical distancing, masks or social bubbles when used in various settings.

Their paper was published Nov. 19 in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America (PNAS).

They introduce the concept of "event R," which is the expected number of people who become infected with COVID-19 from one individual at an event.

Tupper and Colijn look at factors such as transmission intensity, duration of exposure, the proximity of individuals and degree of mixing -- then examine what methods are most effective at preventing transmission in each circumstance.

The researchers incorporated data from reports of outbreaks at a range of events, such as parties, meals, nightclubs, public transit and restaurants. The researchers say that an individual s chances of becoming infected with COVID-19 depend heavily on the transmission rate and the duration -- the amount of time spent in a particular setting.

advertisement

Events were categorized as saturating (high transmission probability) or linear (low transmission probability). Examples of high transmission settings include bars, nightclubs and overcrowded workplaces while low transmission settings include public transit with masks, distancing in restaurants and outdoor activities.

The model suggests that physical distancing was effective at reducing COVID-19 transmission in all settings but the effectiveness of social bubbles depends on whether chances of transmission are high or low.

In settings where there is mixing and the probability of transmission is high, such as crowded indoor workplaces, bars and nightclubs and high schools, having strict social bubbles can help reduce the spread of COVID-19.

The researchers found that social bubbles are less effective in low transmission settings or activities where there is mixing, such as engaging in outdoor activities, working in spaced offices or travelling on public transportation wearing masks.

They note that masks and other physical barriers may be less effective in saturating, high transmission settings (parties, choirs, restaurant kitchens, crowded offices, nightclubs and bars) because even if masks halve the transmission rates that may not have much impact on the transmission probability (and so on the number of infections).

The novel coronavirus is relatively new but the science continues to evolve and increase our knowledge of how to effectively treat and prevent this highly contagious virus. There is still much that we do not know and many areas requiring further study.

"It would be great to start collecting information from exposures and outbreaks: the number of attendees, the amount of mixing, the levels of crowding, the noise level and the duration of the event," says Colijn, who holds a Canada Research Chair in Mathematics for Evolution, Infection and Public Health.

Materials provided by Simon Fraser University . Note: Content may be edited for style and length.

Simon Fraser University. "Researchers examine which approaches are most effective at reducing COVID-19 spread: Social bubbles and masks more situation-dependent in terms of effectiveness." ScienceDaily. ScienceDaily, 20 November 2020. .

Simon Fraser University. "Researchers examine which approaches are most effective at reducing COVID-19 spread: Social bubbles and masks more situation-dependent in terms of effectiveness." ScienceDaily. www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2020/11/201120150726.htm (accessed November 20, 2020).

advertisement

1

Oct. 26, 2020 — The Contagion Airborne Transmission inequality model illustrates correlation between physical distancing and protection, the efficacy of face masks and the impact of physical activity on ...

July 30, 2020 — Researchers have found that the implementation of social distancing policies corresponded with significant reductions in transmission of the SARS-CoV-2 virus and reduced community mobility, both in ...

July 24, 2020 — If physical distancing measures in the United States are relaxed while there is still no COVID-19 vaccine or treatment and while personal protective equipment remains in short supply, the number of ...

June 1, 2020 — A new analysis of COVID-19 outbreaks in 58 cities has found that places that took longer to begin implementing social distancing measures spent more time with the virus rapidly spreading than others ...
Read more on sciencedaily.com
News Topics :
RELATED STORIES :
Top Stories
British Columbia could soon have the highest number of active COVID 19 cases in the country if the virus continues to be transmitted at its current rate, say experts. The province...
Health
As a disease modelling expert, she says the effects of the measures we re taking today to limit the spread of the novel coronavirus may not appear for weeks. But...
Canada
VANCOUVER As B.C.s provincial heath officer called on people to slow down social interactions heading into the fall, a university professor studying the growth in COVID 19 cases...
Science
If physical distancing measures in the United States are relaxed while there is still no COVID 19 vaccine or treatment and while personal protective equipment remains in short supply, the number...
Canada
TORONTO Keeping the novel coronavirus at bay will require many more months of physical distancing, ramped up testing and contact tracing, quarantining and workplace and community closures to...