News

Singh says Bill 21 is discriminatory but stops short of committing to court challenge

Singh says Bill 21 is discriminatory but stops short of committing to court challenge
Top Stories
OTTAWA -- NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh says Quebecs secularism law is undoubtedly discriminatory, but wont commit to federal intervention if elected prime minister.

In an interview with CTV National News on Thursday, Singh said hes waiting to see how the current court challenge of Bill 21 plays out before making that decision.

Its being fought in court right now, and its important that its fought in court. As a lawyer I know that these decisions can be very complex, and so I wouldnt assess anything before we know what happened, he said.

Singh says the law, which prevents public service workers like teachers, judges and police officers from donning religious symbols on the job, is discriminatory. But he said hes less concerned about labels than he is about action.

Its important to note that calling things different labels doesnt help in the battle against systemic racism. What I want to do is make sure people know that they should be valued and they should belong for who they are, he said.

Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau, on the other hand, says he disagrees with the law but wont go as far as to call it discriminatory. He has, however, said that hes keeping the door open to a court challenge at a later date if need be.

Conservative Leader Erin OToole has said that as prime minister, he would never challenge a law passed by a provincial legislature.

In the same interview, Singh skirted around questions about whether hed keep or sell the already-purchased Trans Mountain pipeline, given he is openly opposed to it.

I ve always learned, my mom always taught me, that we need to make sure we make good decisions, and a good decision is only made when you know what you re what you re up against. We don t know what Mr. Trudeau has done, and we don t know the situation. Until we re in government, we ll know that better, he said.

He added that an elected NDP government would end fossil fuel subsides and make more realistic emissions reduction targets although at least one environmental economist has questioned the plans feasibility .

The NDP has vowed that by 2030, Canada would have carbon dioxide emissions at 50 per cent below 2005 levels. By comparison, the Liberals are promising to cut emissions 40 to 45 per cent below 2005 levels by the end of the decade, while the Conservatives want to follow Canadas reduction target under the Paris Agreement which is lower than the governments current goal.

Here is the full text of Singhs interview with CTV News National Affairs Correspondent Omar Sachedina.

Note: This transcript has been edited for length and grammar.

Sachedina: Your platform pledges more than $200 billion in spending over the next five years and relies on new taxes on the so called ultra-rich and also corporations as well to generate more revenue. Do you not run the risk of killing innovation at a time when economic growth is so important for Canada s post-pandemic recovery?

Singh: No, not at all. What we re looking at is just fairness. It s about making sure that the folks that are using offshore tax havens, and loopholes that mean that they re not paying their fair share, start to pay their fair share, and so it s just a really a question of fairness. When we see workers that have struggled in this pandemic, small businesses that have shut their door, but we see the wealthiest 44 billionaires in Canada increase their wealth by $78 billion, and continue not to pay their fair share, it s something that Canadians say doesn t sit well with them.

Sachedina: I want to move on to the Trans Mountain pipeline now. You say that youre against it, youve said that repeatedly. But you won t say what you ll do with it. Don t voters deserve to know what your plan is?

Singh: Well voters know where I stand and they know where I stand on theenvironment.

Sachedina: But they dont know what youre going to do with it.

Singh: They know where I stand on the environment, and they know the things that I would concretely do right away. They know that

I would end fossil fuel subsides, while Trudeau increased them to the level of Mr. Harper.

Sachedina: Specifically on the pipeline, which you know is now a taxpayer-owned asset: If you re elected, what will you do with it? Will you keep it or will you get rid of it?

Singh: I ve always learned, my mom always taught me that we need to make sure we make good decisions, and a good decision is only made when you know what you re what you re up against. We don t know what Mr. Trudeau has done, and we don t know the situation. Until we re in government, we ll know that better.

Sachedina: You want to assess the decision of whether to keep it or sell it. Whats the criteria there, what will you be looking at?

Singh: All the parameters involved with making a decision, what s in the best interest of Canadians, what s the state of the asset, what s the best decision possible we can take?

Sachedina: I want to move on to Bill 21, this is an issue where for you, the personal and the political really collide, right. If you were in Quebec, you would not be able to be a public prosecutor, even a teacher. The Liberals are at least open to intervening in a legal challenge, are you?

Singh: What I ve said about this bill is that it s being fought right now in court. It s a bill that s divisive and I don t support those types of bills.

Sachedina: The question was very direct, Mr. Singh: will you intervene, are you at least open to intervening?

Singh: My position is its being fought in court right now, and it s important that it s fought in court. As a lawyer, I know that these decisions can be very complex, and so I wouldn t assess anything before we know what happens.

Sachedina: Is it racist?

Singh: Calling people racist or labelling things as racist is less important to me than actually getting the results, and the results for me would be a society where people belong, where we don t have police violence based on someone s colour of their skin, where people are not being treated differently because of who they are. That s what I want to achieve.
Read more on CTVnews
News Topics :
RELATED STORIES :
Top Stories
Question Period Host Evan Solomon Ive got to start with the issue of Afghanistan. As you know, you have criticized the Liberal Party in terms of how they handled this...
Top Stories
CTV News National Affairs Correspondent Omar Sachedina speaks with Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau for an interview airing Wednesday, Sept. 15, 2021. Share OTTAWA Libera lLeader Justin Trudeau...
Top Stories
EDMONTON LiberalLeader Justin Trudeaus record on Indigenous reconciliation was called into question Thursday during the English languageleaders debate when NDPLeader Jagmeet Singh cited the controversial legal challenge oftworulings...
Top Stories
OTTAWA Party leaders kicked off the final two week stretch of the 2021 federal election Tuesday with strong words in an effort to distinguish themselves from their opponents,...
Top Stories
TORONTO Green Party Leader Annamie Paul is defending her partys performance in the federal election campaign, with the party trailing in national support polling despite climate change...