Asian leaders worry about Trump’s mixed signals on diplomatic issues
|Toronto Star 11 May 2017 at 20:16|
U.S. navy sailors conduct flight operations on the flight deck of the aircraft carrier USS Carl Vinson in the South China Sea in April 2017. U.S. Secretary of State Rex Tillerson went as far as to say during his confirmation hearing that China’s island-building in the South China Sea was “akin to Russia’s taking of Crimea” and pledged to block access to the islands. (SPC. 3RD CLASS MATT BROWN / U.S. Navy via The New York Times)
By JAVIER C. HERNANDEZThe New York Times
Thu., May 11, 2017
BEIJING—South Korea wants to discuss unease about a U.S. anti-missile system on its soil. Taiwan is eager to buy weapons. The Philippines hopes to find out whether the United States plans to challenge China in the South China Sea.
Leaders across Asia are looking to Washington for guidance on a variety of pressing diplomatic issues.
But ’s erratic approach to policy-making and his focus on one issue — North Korea’s nuclear weapons program — are creating anxiety and confusion in the region.
North Korean missile tests fails hours after UN meetings on nuclear weapons
that Trump is friendly with Xi, the U.S. suddenly seems to care a lot less about those disputed South China Sea islandsEND
Is Trump looking to start a war with China, or is his team just not being clear? Analysis
In South Korea, Trump has angered the public with several remarks, including his suggestion that the country, an ally for over six decades, pay for an anti-missile system built by the United States to deter North Korea. Moon Jae-in, who was elected president of South Korea on Tuesday, has vowed to seek a more conciliatory approach with the North, setting up a potential rift with U.S. policy.
In other parts of Asia, including the Philippines, Taiwan and Vietnam, Trump’s willingness to bend to China is fuelling worries that the United States will stop trying to counter China’s growing influence in the region.
Washington has been the main critic of China’s efforts to build fortresses atop reefs, rocks and islands in the South China Sea. But the Trump administration, apparently wary of angering Beijing, recently decided to suspend patrols of islands and reefs claimed by China.
“The South China Sea is now China’s lake,” said Carlyle A. Thayer, an emeritus professor at the University of New South Wales in Australia.
Trump’s credibility among Asian allies is now at stake, diplomats and analysts say. He may jeopardize longtime economic and security alliances if he does not show a willingness to look beyond North Korea, they say.
The U.S. president also risks pushing countries in the region closer to Beijing if he does not demonstrate that the United States intends to vigorously challenge China’s territorial claims in the sea.
Trump’s supporters say his unpredictable style and willingness to rethink decades of accepted policy may be an asset, especially in dealing with an intractable leader like Kim Jong Un of North Korea. But his lack of assurances to Asian allies and his efforts to please China have created the appearance that his foreign policy is negotiable.
Philippine Defense Chief Delfin Lorenzana, second from right, Armed Forces Chief Gen. Eduardo Ano, right, and other officials inspect the end of the airstrip during their April 2017 visit to Thitu Island off the South China Sea. The Philippines hopes to find out whether the United States plans to challenge China s efforts to build fortresses in the South China Sea. (Bullit Marquez)
Antonio T. Carpio, a Supreme Court justice in the Philippines and a critic of China, said he understood Trump’s focus on North Korea. But he said he worried about the “permanent concessions China may extract from the U.S.”
“Trump’s emerging transactional foreign policy is not reassuring,” he wrote in an email.
South Korea represents one of the more serious rifts that Trump will confront. Moon rose to power by vowing a conciliatory approach to North Korea, saying efforts by the United States and others to impose strict sanctions had fallen short. Trump favours applying maximum pressure on Kim’s government.
In Taiwan, officials worry that the Trump administration may delay arms sales, including F-35 stealth fighter jets, for fear of inflaming tensions with China. China considers Taiwan part of is territory, and it has repeatedly warned the United States against selling weapons to the island.
Trump has already shown a willingness to use Taiwan as a bargaining chip with China. Before he took office, he publicly questioned whether the United States should uphold the “One China” policy. But he later backed down, apparently in an effort to curry favour with President Xi Jinping of China.
China has used Trump’s first few months in office to reinforce its position in the sea, a vast waterway through which more than $5 trillion in trade passes each year. China says historical maps show it owns virtually the entire sea, despite overlapping claims by several smaller countries, including Indonesia, the Philippines and Vietnam.
China now has the ability to deploy warplanes and mobile missile launchers on several islands, according to satellite images provided by the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington. It has recently put the finishing touches on airport hangars and radar systems.
Trump’s young administration has sent mixed signals on how it will approach the dispute. During the campaign, Trump criticized China’s actions in the sea. U.S. Secretary of State Rex Tillerson has suggested that China should be denied access to the islands it built.
But the New York Times reported last week that top Pentagon officials recently turned down a request for a U.S. warship to sail within 12 nautical miles of Scarborough Shoal, a disputed reef claimed by the Philippines and China.
Trump has said that the threat posed by North Korea’s missile tests and nuclear weapons development is so grave that it may require temporarily setting aside contentious issues with China, in exchange for Beijing exerting more political and economic pressure on Pyongyang.
Cheng Xiaohe, an associate professor of international studies at Renmin University in Beijing, said the Trump administration’s decision to halt patrols would send a message that “China’s claims in the sea should be respected and the United States will not challenge that.”
Other countries that claim territory in the sea disagree. Many see it as a patriotic mission to defend territory there against China, and they have grown angry over frequent confrontations with Chinese ships.
Diplomats in the region saw hope in former U.S. president Barack Obama’s talk of sending more military and economic resources to Asia. But they were disappointed as China’s building projects continued unabated.
Trump’s tough talk on China promised a fresh start. Tillerson went as far as to say during his confirmation hearing that China’s island-building in the South China Sea was “akin to Russia’s taking of Crimea” and pledged to block access to the islands.
But the administration has yet to follow through. And power dynamics are quickly shifting, with the Philippines, once one of America’s strongest allies in the region, publicly distancing itself from the United States and embracing China.
Trump’s credibility in the region has also been hurt by his decision to abandon the Trans-Pacific Partnership, a trade pact that was expected to have significant benefits for Southeast Asia.
China, on the other hand, has promised to double down on its investment in the region.
“China sees a golden opportunity to step into the vacuum of leadership in the region,” said Alexander L. Vuving, a professor at the Daniel K. Inouye Asia-Pacific Center for Security Studies in Honolulu.
Trump has spoken in recent days with leaders of the Philippines, Singapore and Thailand, inviting each to the White House. Tillerson has tried to reassure allies that freedom-of-navigation patrols will continue.
Thitinan Pongsudhirak, a professor at Chulalongkorn University in Bangkok, said Trump seemed to be showing genuine interest in building a strategic network in the region. He said Trump was wise to de-emphasize human rights concerns with countries like Thailand and the Philippines; otherwise, it would “further push both countries and the rest of the region into China’s orbit.”
“Once the United States regains some weight and credibility in the region,” he added, “then it can rebalance and reconsider U.S. interests and values.”